This is Why Goodreads Doesn’t Allow Half Stars

why goodreads doesn't allow half starsI think we all agree that Goodreads isn’t perfect. The app is clunky, heck, the website is clunky. Even though as stats nerds, we all use and love it. But there seems to be one specific feature missing the entire book community agrees on: Goodreads doesn’t allow half stars.

And to an extend, I agree. How often does it happen to you that you read a book, and it’s more than a three star rating, but definitely not a four star rating? It happens to me a lot. And these are the moments that I despise Goodreads’ star rating. Because damn, why wouldn’t you allow half stars?

Here’s why
This will be a fairly practical answer. And although Goodreads has never put out a specific statement on this matter, goodreads founder Otis Chandler is among the people who are not fans of half stars.

From a marketing standpoint, half stars are usually not a good idea. The more choices you have, the more you will feel confused about what it is you have to choose – it causes a specific type of stress. Humans will mostly describe thing as something that they disliked, liked, loved or hated. Now categorizing those emotions so clinically into numbers isn’t such an easy feat. For a site to be popular and widely used, it needs to make the user access as convenient as possible. It needs to please the general masses. And there are people who don’t care about cumbersome rating and review systems.

Yes, even a website like Goodreads consists mostly of people that love books in a low key way. You and I are in the minority – loving books so much that we spend a lot of our free time reading and writing about them. And for those masses, the rating system is fine as it is. Adding half stars would just add another layer of stress for them.

When a user experience causes more stress, that usually means the person is less likely to click. Which means less interaction for Goodreads, and less data to collect.

Another thing to point out is that if Goodreads were to suddenly add half stars, all the ratings given to books up to this date would look vastly different from the ratings these books would get in the future, thus screwing with the ratings in general..

Although I sometimes miss half stars, I’m not as bothered by it as I used to. Now, when I want to rate a book 3.5 stars for example, I just rate it three stars and specify my rating in the review section. I always rate down, becuase if I rate up (giving it 4 stars) that would inflate the rating unfairly.

Do you think Goodreads should add half stars? And what do you think about the website in general?


5 thoughts on “This is Why Goodreads Doesn’t Allow Half Stars

  1. I think you made some good points here! I usually round up thought when I have a .5, I think I read somewhere about another reader doing this and followed suit thinking it’d be nicer? and help the author get readers who might like it more than me? but I’ve never thought about the inflation thing….


  2. I love half-stars, but I’m okay that Goodreads doesn’t have them. I DO put them in my review, though, when I feel it’s warranted. Although, I’ve always waffled between rounding up or down. I like your idea of rounding down, though. I never thought of it in terms of inflating the ratings!


    1. I’m the same way!! Yes I definitely like to round down, even though I guess then you’re actually rating the book a little lower than how you actually feel about it? Inflated ratings are just a pet peeve of mine, and I feel like the ratings get inflated anyway because before a book comes out, some people already rate it 5 stars without even reading it, especially when the book is hyped. I like to think that rating down makes things look a little more accurate.


  3. I’m happy there are no half stars, since it limits us to be brutal about the books we read. It makes me consider what the book I’ve read really deserves.
    Plus, as you said, I always add the .5 stars to my review if I feel like the book deserves it 🙂


What's on your mind? :)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s